- Paper Mill
- Parrs Mill
- Pealertown
- Pensyls Mill
- Pine Summit
- Polkville
- Palmer
- Pennline
- Pinney Corners
- Porters Corners
- Pymatuning Central
- Pymatuning North
- Pymatuning South
- Peace Church
- Pine Grove Furnace
- Palmdale
- Paxtang Manor
- Paxton
- Paxton Acres
- Paxton Hollow Estates
- Pennwood
- Piketown
- Pine Acres
- Pine Manor
- Pleasant Hills
- Pleasant Hills
- Pleasant View
- Poplar Gardens
- Poplar Island
- Powells Valley