- Papoose Island
- Peach Island
- Perch River
- Picnic Island
- Picton Island
- Pierrepont Manor
- Pike Island
- Pillar Point
- Pine Island
- Pine Meadows Mobile Home Park
- Pine Ridge Mobile Home Park
- Pinehurst Resort
- Point Peninsula
- Point Vivian
- Poors Island
- Portage Island
- Potter Island
- Pullman Island
- Pullman Island
- Paerdegat
- Parkville
- Plumb Island
- Page
- Parkers
- Parson Mill
- Petries Corners
- Pine Grove
- Pine Island
- Prussian Settlement
- Parkway Mobile Home Park